Book Review, Classics, Fiction

Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte

jane eyre

I will waste no time with summarizing a novel that is two centuries old and just jump right into this spoiler alert: I did not like this book.

What is happening? What am I missing? Why do you guys love Jane Eyre so much?!?

First, let me just say that I do not question the beauty of Charlotte Bronte’s writing. Even though I didn’t like the characters in the story, I found myself thinking about the book while I was away, wondering what was going to happen. This fact alone earns the book a begrudging 2 stars. And only 2. Because some of the chapters dragged on for an eternity, which is why I had to step away from the book for a few days to begin with.

But HONESTLY. I do NOT understand the attraction to Mr. Rochester AT ALL.

He is moody, deceitful, arrogant, emotionally manipulative, and downright selfish. Jane’s falling for him was completely unbelievable, especially considering her feminist rants! She goes from “society expects nothing of me but I am woman hear me roar,” to “yes master” within pages!

Mr. Rochester is one of the worst characters I have ever encountered.

Side bar: Bronte really articulated some intense feminist thought for the era in this book. She was way more explicit than any of Austen’s novels, and I am really confused about how she could say such things as, “I am no bird; and no net ensnares me; I am a free human being, with an independent will; which I now exert to leave you,” (ch. XXIII) and, “It is thoughtless to condemn [women], or laugh at the them, if they seek to do more or learn more than custom has pronounced necessary for their sex,” (ch. XII) yet have such a man as her romantic hero.

Speaking of whom, please consider the following as exhibits 1-4 of Mr. Rochester’s appalling character:

  1. He faked a relationship with Miss Ingram to make Jane jealous, and then has no qualms admitting that to Jane. (ch. XXIV)
  2. He dresses up as a gypsy to deceive Jane and ascertain her feelings about him. (ch. XIX)
  3. He threatens to use violence against Jane when she refuses his proposal after she finds out about his wife – see point 4. (ch. XXVII…actually this whole chapter is just a great example of his temper. And instead of being repulsed by it, Jane blames herself for inciting his rage and tries to placate him! UGH)
  4. He keeps his crazy wife locked up in his attic, has a (likely) lovechild with a French actress and then treats her with disdain, and lies about it all to Jane. (ch. THE WHOLE BOOK)

Lest we think this brushing over of Mr. Rochester’s character is a case of love being blind (which honestly would be bad enough), Jane likewise defends St. John’s character when he pressures her to marry him as well. What is it with these men?! St. John, like Mr. Rochester, is selfish, demanding, and obnoxious. Yet Jane, while acknowledging all of his personality flaws (his coldness, his hardness of heart, his exacting nature – at least he isn’t passionately crazy like Mr. Rochester…), repeatedly calls him “a good and a great man.”  Bronte even ends the book with a meditation on his missionary work.

I would love to read a modern, feminist retelling of this book where Jane gives Mr. Rochester and St. John a piece of her mind.

And before you object, refusing their marriage proposals on principle but then being obsessed with their bad reactions (even though you have the moral high ground) is not truly standing up for yourself, Jane.

I will say I enjoyed the beginning of the book more, probably because I was optimistic about my experience and hopeful for Jane’s. But the last third especially was a trial.

In conclusion, Gothic novels and Byronic heroes are clearly not my jam. Don’t try to change my mind.


3 thoughts on “Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte”

  1. I enjoyed your review of the book, even though I loved Jane Eyre in high school. I think if I read it now I may find it more disturbing than I did before. Your criticism of Mr Rochester is sound but I agree with what others have suggested that sometimes we are drawn to mystery and passion, despite pretty obvious flaws. Hopefully we are not drawn to the flaws themselves! In any case, I have no quarrel with your criticism of Jane, either, how she’s confident and principled one moment and then beating herself up the next. But there’s common human nature in that, too. Anyway, I appreciate your thoughtful review!


  2. Thank you 🙈 honestly the Brontes are such a struggle for me and I too am proud I even tried! And I get what you’re saying about the allegory…still doesn’t redeem it for me. But thanks for your great comment!


  3. UNFOLLOW. Just kidding. 😉 I love this book, partly for the writing, but mostly just because I love, love, love Jane. She’s one of the first and few characters I’ve read whose thoughts feel familiar and real even when her reactions aren’t great. Maybe the reader’s own personality is the make or break ingredient for this book.

    As for her terrible choice in a man, with her background, she’s a prime target for manipulation and abuse. Her ability to leave is what’s inspiring! And if there’s some unrealistic redemption for Mr. R in the end… ah well, I love a happy ending.

    I don’t think it’s a crazy stretch to read the two men as a sort of Allegory for the temptations of life… the war between license and legalism. Both are deadly and Jane holds fast to the narrow way.

    Disagreement on the merits of Jane Eyre notwithstanding, I applaud your attempt to love gothic novels… you’ve definitely earned the right to say “nope.” Xoxo


Leave a Reply to glitterandplato Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s